logo


Task force to assess spiritual condition

By Paula R. Kincaid
The Presbyterian Layman
Volume 34, Number 5
Posted July 6, 2001

LOUISVILLE, Ky. – The General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (USA) voted to appoint a theological task force to lead the denomination in a four-year “spiritual discernment of our Christian identity.”

The discernment is to include the issues of Christology, Biblical authority and interpretation, ordination standards and power. The 17-member task force will be appointed by current General Assembly Moderator Jack Rogers and his two immediate predecessors, Syngman Rhee and Freda Gardner.

The approved task force also is to develop a process and instrument by which congregations and governing bodies may reflect on and discuss the matters that unite and divide the church. It is to make annual progress reports to General Assemblies until the 217th assembly in 2005, at which it will make its final report.

Rogers’ comments
During a press conference concerning the assembly’s action, Rogers said the changes the assembly made to the original theological commission idea “have made it much more a gathering of information from the church as a whole and a reporting back to the church as a whole than it might have been otherwise.”

“Instead of a group of wise people closeting themselves for four years and producing a report saying, ‘This is what we ought to do,’ the assembly has mandated that these people consult very widely in the church and that their results be reported back, not just to the General Assembly but to the church at large. I welcome those modifications to the original task force idea,” he said.

The theological commission, which the overture called for, was changed to a task force by the committee after a presentation by Mark Tammen of the Department of Constitutional Services.

After Tammen explained the differences between task forces, committees and commissions, the Rev. Kim Rodrigue spoke against creating a commission. Commissions, she said, have to be made up of ministers and elders, “which would exclude having any gay or lesbian people on it.” That “already makes it untrustworthy,” she said. There are no constitutional standards dealing with the composition of a task force.

Asked what sort of criteria he will employ to pick the task force members, Rogers said, “I have no idea. We’ll just have to think and consult with others and figure out criteria. My own secret hope is that we can sort of surprise people and find some people nobody expects to be on that task force, but who everybody says later ‘That’s a good idea.’ I don’t have those people in mind.”

Commission to task force
The recommendation came from the Assembly Committee on Peace, Purity and Unity of the Church and was in response to Overture 01-33 from John Calvin Presbytery, which called for a theological commission to study the spiritual condition of the church and the causes for its unrest.

In making the recommendation to the assembly, committee moderator Jenny Stoner said the committee “spent many hours revising this overture” and that 27 motions were considered during the deliberations. “I request you affirm this work.”

The assembly did approve two amendments to the recommendation, one that called for the task force to confer with synods and presbyteries and congregations. The original recommendation called for conferring only with presbyteries and congregations. The other amendment asked the task force not only to make annual progress reports to General Assemblies, but also to presbyteries and sessions.

The General Assembly also approved using the actions taken on the task force to answer several other overtures, including:
  • Overture 01-36 from the Presbytery of Midwest Hanmi – on declaring that a resolution has been reached on the matter of human sexuality related to eligibility for ordination.
  • Overture 01-09 from the Presbytery of Southern Kansas – on entering a process of churchwide spiritual discernment considering the current division within the denomination.
  • Overture 01-14 from the Presbytery of Denver – on appointing a special committee to propose amendments to reaffirm the role of governing bodies on ordination decisions.
  • Overture 01-20 from the Presbytery of Western North Carolina – on calling all members and ordained officers of the church to be reconciled by uniting in a year of study and prayer.
  • Overture 01-42 from the Presbytery of Milwaukee – on establishing a special task force to move beyond the current impasse.
With no debate, the assembly voted to disapprove Overture 00-06 from the Beaver-Butler Presbytery, with a comment. The overture called for appointing a special committee to explore amendments to the Book of Order to permit congregations that cannot comply with G-6.0106b to disaffiliate from the church while retaining real property. The comment stated that the Book of Order has provisions in it for allowing a church to withdraw, though not to retain real property absent presbytery approval.
Respond to this article
Home · News · PLC Publications · The Presbyterian Layman
Online Reviews · Archives · History of the Lay Committee · Feedback · Links